18/09/2020
Last week the branch voted to support this motion on the return to campus and face to face teaching:
MMU UCU statement on the re-opening of campus this term and the resumption of face to face teaching – adopted by branch meeting on 9 September 2020
Since Manchester Met moved teaching online in March, UCU has been in negotiations with University management regarding the means of safely re-opening for teaching in the autumn. However in light of recent scientific evidence and the increasing national incidence of Covid-19 we now believe that the University's currently advertised plans are inadequate to ensure a safe reopening.
The following statement has been especially guided by the Independent SAGE report on universities (20 August), the BMJ editorial 'Re-opening universities is high risk' (1 September) and the SAGE paper on SARS-CoV-2 transmission in higher education (4 September).
We have also taken account of moves towards all-online teaching provision next term at other universities, including St Andrews, QMUL, UCL, Birkbeck, Bournemouth and Ulster.
We note that seven of the ten boroughs in Greater Manchester are on red alert with Bolton having the highest infection rate in the country, and new restrictions on socialising.
To ensure the safety of students, staff, and wider community, we call on the University to adopt the principle for the autumn term that anything that can be done off campus, should be done off campus.
Every unnecessary footfall on campus increases the danger of an outbreak in the university community and endangers the continuation of those activities that need to be done on campus.
We call on the University:
(1) To move all teaching online for the autumn term, with the exception of any necessary lab-based and practice-based teaching.
This is the recommendation of the Independent SAGE report . In the case of lab-based and practice-based teaching the teaching mode should be decided by the teaching and technical staff involved.
(2) To allow students to cancel or defer accommodation contracts with the University without penalties if they wish to.
This will demonstrate that the University is not prioritising financial concerns over the health of students and staff.
(3) To continue to welcome to campus and provide support for those students who feel they cannot study effectively at home.
Please see the statement by Larissa Kennedy, NUS President, in the UCU event on reopening universities and colleges (from 27:50) explaining the kinds of circumstances involved.
(4) To ensure that students who decide not to move to campus or the Manchester area are properly supported to undertake their studies from home.
In particular, the University needs to ensure that students studying from home have adequate wifi connections, equipment to access teaching, and pastoral support.
(5) To confirm in writing to staff and line managers that return to work on campus this term will be on a voluntary basis.
Arrangements should be made that, subject to individual risk assessments alongside building risk assessments, those staff who may wish to work on campus are utilised to perform necessary roles that can only be done on campus.
(6) To guarantee that staff who do not opt to work on campus and who can work from home will not suffer any loss of income, job security or detriment to career progression.
(7) To establish arrangements to carefully monitor the mental health and stress levels of all staff and to ensure action is taken in case of any concerns.
The Health and Safety Executive Management Standards set out ‘six key areas of work design that, if not properly managed, are associated with poor health, lower productivity and increased accident and sickness absence rates’. All six of these are in flux in the current context, and thus require active and consistent risk assessment.
(8) To adopt the principle that all interactions that need to take place on campus will be done with mitigations to ensure the lowest level of risk as assessed by the recent BMJ article 'Two metres or one: what is the evidence for physical distancing in Covid-19?' (25 August).
In particular, all prolonged indoor interactions such as teaching there should be all three of: a well ventilated space, social distancing of 2 metres, and the wearing of face coverings. By 'well ventilated' we understand the six air changes per hour recommended as a minimum by the US CDC in their Guidelines for environmental infection control in health-care facilities (July 2019), p.50, whether this is achieved by ventilation systems or by window opening.
(9) To test all students for Covid-19 on or before arrival and thereafter regularly throughout the term, or else to take measures that will be similarly effective in preventing outbreaks in the university community
It is now generally accepted that comprehensive and regular testing is the only way to prevent outbreaks at universities. Cardiff, Portsmouth and UEA are taking steps in this direction.
(10) To commit to publishing a daily dashboard showing the numbers of tests, cases, hospital admissions, and deaths among students and staff.
A large number of universities in the US publish daily dashboards, and the BMJ editorial referred to above rightly says that they are needed for both transparency and accountability.
(11) to organise an urgent meeting to discuss these issues
This Branch therefore Resolves
(A) to have as its aim in talks to achieve the above detailed position.
(B) in the event that position is not achieved immediately the branch will continue to negotiate and critique the Risk Assessments relying on the latest scientific evidence to push for our position.
(C) in the event the University decides to ignore scientific evidence and to put students staff and the community at risk UCU will provide advice to members about their individual rights in law.
(D) any member who individually decides to invoke their rights in the face of the serious and imminent danger Covid19 may present to them will receive the full support of the branch.
(E) if any member who exercises their rights under s44 ERA suffers a detriment or is dismissed the branch will convene an emergency Members meeting to discuss the Branch’s support
