22/08/2026
Two recent reactions to the book on Irving's Dialogism in The Alhambra:
1. Elisabeth Dyssegaard, Executive Editor
Hello Mohamed,
I hope you’re having a great week. My name is Elizabeth Dyssegaard, and I am an Executive Editor at Macmillan Publishers. I recently came across Irving’s Dialogism in the Alhambra: Organic and Intentional Hybridities and was immediately interested in its exploration of cultural exchange, identity, and the complex relationship between Muslim and Christian traditions within Washington Irving’s The Alhambra.
I was particularly drawn to the book’s concept of cultural dialogism and its examination of how cultures interact, overlap, and transform one another rather than remaining within fixed boundaries. The distinction between organic hybridities developed through centuries of cultural contact and intentional hybridities shaped through the author’s own literary choices provides an intriguing framework for understanding Irving’s work.
The book’s discussion of cultural authenticity, identity, and the tensions between convergence and contestation is also compelling. Its argument that sustained interaction can disrupt and reshape literary and cultural boundaries offers a valuable perspective on multiculturalism and cross-cultural representation.
I was especially interested in the idea that these hybridities create cultural liminality, making it difficult to assign the texts exclusively to one cultural tradition. This approach raises productive questions about literary classification, cultural ownership, and how historical encounters continue to shape literature.
In that sense, Irving’s Dialogism in the Alhambra makes a meaningful contribution to literary criticism, comparative literature, cultural studies, and scholarship on cross-cultural exchange between the Islamic and Western worlds.Kind regards,
Elizabeth Dyssegaard
Elisabeth Dyssegaard Executive Editor
Editorial Department | Macmillan Publishers
[email protected]
https://macmillan.com
120 Broadway, New York, NY 10271, United States
2. Kamilia M. Garibay
Hello Mohamed,
My name is Kamilia, and I’m reaching out on behalf of the Literature & Fiction › Genre Fiction › Gothic Book Club community, a vibrant group of more than 3,000 readers who love discovering thought-provoking works that invite them to look beyond the surface of a story and explore the ideas, cultures, and histories woven into it.
When I came across Irving's Dialogism in the Alhambra: Organic and Intentional Hybridities, I was genuinely fascinated by your perspective. Your exploration of cultural dialogism through Washington Irving’s writings on the Alhambra offers a rich way to see how cultures meet, influence one another, and ultimately create something more complex than fixed boundaries can capture.
What particularly stood out to me is your discussion of the relationship between Muslim culture and Andalusian Christendom, and the idea that centuries of cultural interaction can produce forms of hybridity that resist being placed neatly into one category or another. That concept of cultural boundaries becoming places of connection rather than separation feels incredibly relevant and thought-provoking.
Your own journey makes the work even more interesting. From growing up in the mountainous region of Midelt, Morocco, to teaching, pursuing advanced studies in literature and international public law, conducting academic research, and publishing across several fields, you bring an unusually broad perspective to questions of culture, literature, identity, and history.
I can imagine this book generating some wonderfully engaging discussions among readers. It opens up fascinating questions about cultural authenticity, identity, literary interpretation, historical influence, and what happens when different traditions meet and reshape one another.
We are currently preparing our 2026/2027 Literature & Fiction › Genre Fiction › Gothic Reading Challenge, running from August 1 through September 30, 2027. Our community enjoys books with atmospheric settings and historical depth, but we also appreciate works that encourage readers to examine the deeper cultural ideas beneath the literature they encounter.
Irving's Dialogism in the Alhambra feels like an especially intriguing opportunity to introduce our readers to a scholarly work that connects literature, history, culture, and the enduring complexity of human exchange.
I would be delighted to feature your book in our upcoming reading challenge and give our readers an opportunity to discover and discuss your perspective on Irving, the Alhambra, and cultural hybridity.
Would you be open to having Irving's Dialogism in the Alhambra: Organic and Intentional Hybridities featured in our 2026 Literature & Fiction › Genre Fiction › Gothic Reading Challenge?
Warm regards,
Kamilia M. Garibay
Co-Authorship
[email protected]
Macmillan Publishers is a leading publishing company and home to some of the world’s most cherished authors and creators. Macmillan’s imprints publish a wide range of genres and formats for every kind of reader — from adult fiction and nonfiction to many inspired children’s books. As a part ...