09/23/2026
During the last five years of her life, every visit with my grandmother
was an internal goodbye ceremony for me. I vividly remember standing at the bottom of the stairs as she waved at me, while I savored her and the
feeling of her hug. I can still close my eyes and relive that moment.
I knew it might be the last visit, so I looked at her more carefully. I smelled her unique grandma smell (I swear I can still smell it in my memory). I tried to absorb every detail that would normally disappear without my noticing. I left her home carrying the sadness of losing her, even though she was still alive. And only now I realize how helpful it has been for my mental health.
We tend to imagine goodbye as one definitive moment: the final conversation, the last embrace, the closing of a door. But emotionally, goodbye is rarely a single event. It often begins long before someone leaves and continues long after they are gone.
In Psychology, there is a name for the strange experience of grieving someone who is still here: Anticipatory Grief. You feel grateful for their presence, while another part of you is already mourning their absence. You hold them, yet imagine the time when you will no longer be able to hold them.
Anticipatory grief asks the heart to perform an impossible task: to keep someone close while slowly preparing to release them.
Perhaps, during those visits, some part of me believed that if I paid enough attention, I could preserve my grandmother. If I said goodbye properly, I might have fewer regrets. If I began grieving early, perhaps the final loss would hurt less.
But love cannot be paid for in advance. Grieving someone before they die does not exempt us from grieving after their death.
These internal goodbyes also carry a danger. We can become so occupied with preserving a moment that we stop inhabiting it. The visit becomes a future memory before it has finished being a present experience. There is a delicate difference between knowing that someone will be gone and treating them as though they are already gone.
A healthy goodbye does something different. It does not ask us to leave the relationship early. It returns us more fully to the person who is still here.
Awareness of limited time can remind us to listen with greater patience, ask the questions we have postponed, express our gratitude, and notice the ordinary details of someone’s presence. It encourages us to stop waiting for a “better time” to say what matters.
This reminds me of the idea of positive mortality (I'll write about it some other time), where we embrace our mortality so we can live fully.
I do not know whether those internal ceremonies prepared me to lose my grandmother. I suspect that nothing could have prepared me. But they taught me to notice her more carefully.
Years later, I can close my eyes and find myself standing at the bottom of those stairs again. She is still there, waving.