08/18/2026
We like the idea that our self is stable and consistent, something that feels reliable. In reality, different parts of us emerge depending on who we are with.
One of my therapy clients described this fluctuation: There are people around whom I become funnier. Others make me quieter. Around some people, I find myself apologizing before I have done anything wrong. Around others, I speak with a confidence I didn’t know I have.
For years he believed that his personality belonged entirely to him. Through our work together, he began noticing that different people seemed to summon entirely different versions of him.
Think of the person around whom you feel most like yourself. Now think of someone around whom you become smaller, more careful, or less recognizable. Perhaps one of the most important questions we can ask about a relationship is not simply, ‘Do I love this person?’ It is, ‘Who do I become when I am with them?’
We do not carry one fixed personality unchanged from room to room. Different relationships awaken different memories, expectations, defenses, and possibilities within us.
Others’ expectations can shape our sense of self and our behavior. People who have known us for a long time may unintentionally continue relating to us as our old self. In their presence, we can find ourselves returning to an old role long after we have outgrown it.
This leads to a more challenging insight about relationships: we can love someone deeply and still dislike the person we repeatedly become around them. Evaluating a relationship may require us to look not only at how we feel about the other person, but also at how they shape our own way of being.
In psychology, we call it the Michelangelo phenomenon: close relationships “sculpt” us toward - or away from - our ideal self. People who recognize and support the person you hope to become can make that version of you easier to find and express.
This is not about blaming other people for the versions of ourselves that emerge around them. Relationships are co-created, shaped by both people’s histories, expectations, fears, and patterns. Still, the person we repeatedly become in a relationship is important information.
Every relationship is a room with its own emotional climate. In some rooms we stretch out and breathe deeply; in others we instinctively make ourselves smaller.
We may not choose every relationship in our lives, but we can become more conscious within each one. Sometimes, simply noticing who we become is the first step toward choosing a different way of being.
Which relationships allow more of you to exist?