06/06/2026
In February, two teams traveled to New Orleans for the Mardi Gras Moot Court Invitational hosted by Tulane University Law School. This year's problem focused on the overlap between the rapidly evolving NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) markets for college players, the NCAA's 5-year eligibility rule, and the Sherman Antitrust Act. Competitors represented either the NCAA or a fictional college quarterback named William Spears, arguing whether the NCAA's inclusion of Junior Colleges in their 5-year eligibility rule constituted a violation of the Sherman Act.
The teams argued their preliminary rounds in the federal courthouse for the Eastern District of Louisiana, competing against 27 other schools for a chance to argue in the elimination rounds at Tulane's Law School.
The team of Emily Briney (3L), Darian Morgan (2L), and Benjamin Calcaterra (2L) had one of the toughest draws for preliminary rounds that is possible. Emily, Darian, and Ben wound up arguing their 3 preliminary rounds against the teams that would ultimately place 1st, 2na, and 3rd overall in the competition. The 3rd overall team also had the 1st place brief.
Despite this incredibly difficult matchup, Emily, Darian, and Ben competed like true champions!
The team of Jacob Leonard (2L), Sydney Packard (2L), and Andrew Cristea (3L), took 4th place overall in the competition.
Despite being eliminated at the semifinal round, Jacob, Sydney, and Andrew argued incredibly well in their final round - so much so, in fact, that the 4 judges announced during feedback that the score was tied at 2-2 and ultimately broken by a very close total oralist score. The team that moved on from that round ultimately won the competition, as well as 1st-and 3rd-place oralists.
We are incredibly proud of both teams. They worked incredibly hard in the lead-up to the competition and represented SIU Simmons with poise and class. The judges universally remarked that our teams were incredibly respectful and composed, and that they had a remarkable grasp of the problem and the law involved. We have two more competitions coming up this year, and we cannot wait to see the continued success of our Board members!