10/11/2026
✨ Read along with us this month! For October, we are discussing THEY WISH THEY WERE US by Jessica Goodman. This month our genre is Dark Academia, so we're heading to an elite prep school on Long Island filled with privilege, perfection, secret societies, and murder. Think Gossip Girl meets a twisty mystery with a dash of The Secret History. Perfect reading for spooky season! ✨
📖 About the book:
At Gold Coast Prep, everything looks perfect—from the manicured grounds and pressed uniforms to the beautiful, ambitious students. But Jill Newman knows better. Three years ago, her best friend Shaila was murdered, and her boyfriend confessed. The case was closed.
Now it's Jill's senior year, and she's determined to make it her best yet. As one of the Players, Gold Coast Prep's exclusive secret society, she has access to the best parties, the highest status, and everything she's worked toward.
But then Jill starts receiving messages claiming that Graham didn't kill Shaila.
If he's innocent, the real killer may still be out there—and uncovering the truth could put Jill's friendships, future, and entire world at risk. A fast-paced mystery about friendship, privilege, ambition, and the dangerous pursuit of perfection